Successful Advertising

Earlier today, I saw a Manwich commercial.

I don’t remember anything about this commercial, except that the product advertised was a Manwich.

Consequently, I now very much want a Manwich.

Compare this to the flashy commercial full of CGI and flying robots and a thousand quotes from various reviewers trumpeting the virtues of this particular smartphone.

I recall this commercial clearly, but I have no idea which smartphone it was intended to advertise.

Which, then, is the more successful ad?